Biblical Termgenealogytoledothcovenant

Toledoth

About Toledoth

Toledoth is the Hebrew word at the heart of a heading that, as Jason S. DeRouchie notes in a 2013 article in the Journal of the Evangelical Theological Society, is "often translated" as "this is the account of" or "these are the generations of". Marten H. Woudstra, in a 1970 article in the Calvin Theological Journal, traces the word to the root yalad, "to bear" or "to generate", explains that it "refers to the product of bearing", and counts ten toledoth divisions in the book of Genesis. DeRouchie counts the formula "10 (11)" times in the book, because he takes the second heading for Esau, at Genesis 36:9, as "secondary to the overall structure of the book", and he judges that its "recurring placement suggests that the author used it as a shaping device for his work." The Zondervan Pictorial Encyclopedia of the Bible (1975) adds that the word "may well refer also to family history in general".

The headings of Genesis

The first heading is "the account of the heavens and the earth when they were created" (Genesis 2:4). Then come "the book of the generations of Adam" (Genesis 5:1) and the accounts of Noah (Genesis 6:9), of Noah's sons Shem, Ham and Japheth (Genesis 10:1), of Shem (Genesis 11:10) and of Terah, who "became the father of Abram, Nahor, and Haran" (Genesis 11:27). Next come the accounts of Abraham's sons Ishmael (Genesis 25:12) and Isaac (Genesis 25:19), and two for Esau, "that is, Edom" and "the father of the Edomites" (Genesis 36:1, 9). The last is "the account of Jacob" (Genesis 37:2), which turns at once to his son Joseph, "seventeen years old" and tending the flock with his brothers. DeRouchie reads the headings as tracing "the chosen line of promise": Isaac "is given preference over Ishmael, Jacob over Esau," and while the accounts of Isaac and Jacob "carry forward the blessing-commission," the segmented genealogies of Ishmael and Esau "principally highlight the rejected lines".

Outside Genesis

The same wording heads "the account of Aaron and Moses at the time the LORD spoke with Moses on Mount Sinai" (Numbers 3:1). In the book of Ruth, "these are the generations of Perez" open a line that runs through Boaz to "Jesse, and Jesse was the father of David" (Ruth 4:18-22). DeRouchie takes these two "occurrences of the same toledot pattern" as support for "reading the instances in Genesis as headings to what follows".

Heading or closing line?

DeRouchie notes that "the majority of classic source critics" have read the first heading, at Genesis 2:4a, "as a subscript", a closing line to what comes before it. The colophon theory, as DeRouchie traces it, goes back to P. J. Wiseman, who in New Discoveries in Babylonia about Genesis (1936) took every formula as a closing line, drawing on what DeRouchie calls "supposed parallels" with Mesopotamian cuneiform tablets. DeRouchie adds that R. K. Harrison, "years later", "vigorously defended his case" in Introduction to the Old Testament (1969). In that model, DeRouchie explains, the first 36 chapters of Genesis rest on eleven tablets, and the count is eleven because Wiseman and Harrison "take Gen 36:9 as its own toledot marker". Scholars who hold the theory take the names in the headings to be those of the people who held the clay tablets that Moses used, tablets passed down through Abraham and the other patriarchs.

Alan Millard, in a 2011 memoir, judges that Wiseman's books "broke new ground in reading biblical texts beside Babylonian" but "have not carried conviction". DeRouchie holds that "a number of reasons call for the rejection of the colophon theory", among them that the five headings that open a genealogy, those for Adam, Noah's sons, Shem, Ishmael and the first for Esau, are "most naturally read with what follows".

Genealogies

The Zondervan Pictorial Encyclopedia of the Bible (1975) states that "many OT genealogies are incomplete" and holds that "Canaan was the father of Sidon his firstborn" (Genesis 10:15) does not mean that Sidon was his son. In the book of Ezra, men who "searched for their family records, but they could not find them" were "excluded from the priesthood as unclean" (Ezra 2:62).

Related Questions

Scripture References

Ezra 2:62Genesis 5Genesis 11Genesis 2:4Genesis 6:9Genesis 10:1Genesis 25:12Genesis 25:19Genesis 36:1Genesis 36:9Genesis 37:2Numbers 3:1Ruth 4:18-22Genesis 10:15