Biblical Archaeologist

John Bimson

About John Bimson

John Bimson is an Old Testament scholar who has taught at Trinity College, Bristol. He is the author of Redating the Exodus and Conquest, first published in 1978 by JSOT Press in Sheffield as number 5 in the JSOT Supplement Series, with a second edition from the Almond Press, Sheffield, in 1981. In Bimson's own summary of its case, "the Exodus has been dated too late and the end of the MBA has been dated too early," the MBA being the Middle Bronze Age. The book grew out of Bimson's doctoral thesis in the Department of Biblical Studies at Sheffield University.


The question the book answers

According to 1 Kings 6:1, Solomon began to build the house of the LORD in his fourth year, "in the four hundred and eightieth year after the Israelites had come out of the land of Egypt." With the temple begun in 966 BC, the 480 years place the Exodus in 1446 BC, and after the forty years in the wilderness (Numbers 32:13; Joshua 5:6) the conquest begins about 1406 BC. A later date, about 1250 BC, is also proposed; the wider debate is set out on the Dating the Exodus page.

Bimson judged that the figure of 480 years, a multiple of 12 and 40, should probably not be taken as an exact count of years, though it is not to be set aside as worthless. Bimson read it beside the three hundred years of Judges 11:26 as a reason not to squeeze the era of the judges into the 170 years from 1200 to 1030 BC.


What the book argued

Bimson proposed lowering the end of the Middle Bronze Age in the Levant, which he notes has usually been dated between 1580 and 1550 BC, from the 16th century into the second half of the 15th. On Bimson's scheme the destroyed cities of the Middle Bronze II phase fell in the 15th century rather than the 16th, and their destroyers were the Israelite tribes who had left Egypt in the first half of that century. Bimson dated the start of the conquest to "the decades around 1430 BC," and, provisionally, the Exodus to about 1470 BC, with the attack on Jericho about 1430 BC after a full forty years in the wilderness.

At Jericho the archaeologist Kathleen Kenyon, who excavated the site, dated the city's destruction to about 1550 BC and held that the site was then abandoned. In Bimson's words, those conclusions "dispose completely of an early date for the Exodus" unless the Jericho account is rejected outright. Bimson's answer was that Jericho's Middle Bronze city ended during the latter half of the 15th century BC, falling to the Israelites at the fall of Jericho, when the wall collapsed and the city was burned (Joshua 6:20, 6:24).

The book's section on Hazor reviews the excavations there, among them those of the excavator Yadin. For the conquest of Hazor (Joshua 11:10-13), Bimson held that the city Joshua's forces destroyed was the last phase of the Middle Bronze Age city at Hazor. Bimson equated the later destruction of the Late Bronze Age city there, in the latter half of the 13th century, with the destruction of Jabin, king of Canaan, who reigned in Hazor (Judges 4:2, 4:24).

The book treats the conquest of Ai (Joshua 8:28) under the heading "The Problem-City of Ai." Bimson suggested that the long-held identification of Ai with Khirbet et-Tell may be mistaken, and granted that, since remains from the Middle Bronze Age are absent there, his own theory does nothing to resolve the difficulty.

Bimson argued that once the Exodus is placed before the 13th century BC, the many destructions of towns in that century and early in the 12th belong to the period of the Judges, when there was "no shortage of alternative agents of destruction."


How it was received

Reviewing the book in Themelios in 1982, D. J. Wiseman wrote that its "thorough re-examination of the evidence" for the date of the Exodus and the entry into Palestine "must not be ignored." Wiseman counted the archaeological evidence from Jericho, Hazor and other sites among its strong points, and noted that some reviewers had treated it as merely a "vigorously argued defence of a fifteenth-century date." Only time would tell, Wiseman added, whether Palestinian archaeologists in general would accept moving destruction levels usually tied to the 13th century back to the 15th.

Writing in the Grace Theological Journal in 1983, Gerald L. Mattingly found that the book had received mixed reviews since 1978, and called it the most thorough and current study of the historical and archaeological data for the exodus and conquest, though he expected many readers to have reservations. Mattingly reports that J. M. Miller, reviewing it in the Journal of Biblical Literature in 1980, found the theory plausible but judged that the secondary explanations it needs cancel its advantage over the hypothesis of a 13th-century date.


Other writing

In a 1980 chapter on archaeological data and the dating of the patriarchs, in Essays on the Patriarchal Narratives, Bimson argued that matching the lives of Abraham and Isaac with the period he calls Middle Bronze I places Abraham's life "largely, if not entirely, before 2000 BC," a setting he judged "in accord with the biblical dating of the patriarchs." Bimson was a contributing editor of the New Bible Atlas (Inter-Varsity Press, 1985) and consulting editor of the Illustrated Encyclopedia of Bible Places, which Inter-Varsity Press published in 1995.